Sample candidate writing responses and examiner comments the academic writing test consists of two tasks, task 1 and task 2 each task is assessed independently. I seldom comment, however i did some searching and wound up here 4 things you should know about choosing examiners for your thesis | the thesis whisperer and i actually. This thesis examines organizational culture and identity, and uses them to frame and explain the structure, strategies, behaviour and performance of a professional sporting organization.
Examiners are requested on this form to comment on the extent to which the thesis meets the criteria for the award of the phd (see below), to detail any required amendments, to identify questions to be addressed in the oral examination, and provide any additional comments or guidance to the candidate. What the examiners said in australia, a thesis must be submitted to three examiners: one in the university and two external, one of whom must be overseas the comments are sent back to the examinations committee, who decide whether the candidate's thesis is. If an examiner finds that he/she is not qualified to comment on aspects of the thesis which are considered to be significant to the argument or conclusion, they should notify the school of graduate research by email, without waiting to submit the final report on the thesis. The thesis does not have to be reexamined, nor do i have to defend both examiners submitted tons of comments and constructive criticisms, including general statements about the work as a whole and all the tiny nitpicky things you'd expect.
A sample thesis report, showing the reader the wonder of formatting documents using latex claire connelly melissa o'neill, advisor second reader, reader. Examiner's editorial comments on the thesis should not be discussed at the oral examination it is recommended that each examiner hand the student a list of any. • make the corrections that you and supervisor have agreed upon to an electronic copy of your thesis • prepare a response to the examiners' comments as you would for a journal. Examiners are encouraged to make special mention of a thesis they believe is of exceptional quality thesis merit the merit descriptions are based on the agreement between go8 deans of graduate research, australia to enable appropriate bench marking.
Thesis management - comments these fields relate to the treatment of the thesis and examiners once the evaluation process has been completed field or control. Examiners' reports on theses: feedback or assessment the examiners are asked to comment on the thesis with reference to the description of the degree (see. The examiners of a friend's phd thesis required revisions which they needed to approve before they would accept the thesis the requirements were fairly demanding but overall reasonable and helpfully. 3 simple and effective comment styling tips for thesis thesis makes styling your own comments simple because it automatically detects comments left by the. Sample report based on authentic comments from external examiners: for training purposes only 1 your participation in the moderation process.
Graphic layout issues examiner one a copy of this previous thesis was unfortunately not able to be discovered during the comments on actor network theory. Answers to the comments of foreigner examiner comment-1 there are few corrections which have made in the thesis i have marked these in the margins of. Jakarta, 27 january 2016 look at the bright side the beauty of having to revise your phd thesis is that you have both the experience of writing and submitting, as well as rewriting and resubmitting the thesis. Thesis form 6: feedback for thesis-external examiner 2015 feedback for thesis: external examiner re-examination by internal examiner only, who ensures comments of. Examiners are asked to address both the strengths and weaknesses of the thesis or exegesis and creative work and to provide detailed comments about the overall quality of the thesis or exegesis and creative work, paying attention to things such as.
3 thesis examination home the request for an oral thesis examination is indicated on the nomination of thesis examiners form send us your comments or. Thesis examiners the following information is intended for examiners involved in a thesis examinationinformation about examiner requirements, the honorarium and the expected timeline for completion of the examination process is presented. Comments on both the strengths and weaknesses of the thesis the research higher degrees committee is aware that both theses and examiners' reports can differ substantially in their format and style, but the committee would appreciate each. Examiners' joint report on a thesis submitted for a research degree please note: this report will be shared with the candidate and their department following approval by the chair of the appropriate graduate studies committee.
The agony and the ecstasy: making post viva corrections do not rewrite your thesis only attend to what the examiners have requested any comments or. Investigating phd thesis examination reports underlying examiner comments about flaws in the design and conduct of the study or in the analysis and interpretation.
The examiners are asked to comment on the thesis with reference t o the description of the degree (see introduction above) examiners are requested to respond to the following q uestions. Master's thesis/phd dissertation evaluation category rating comments research questions/set-up literature review theory/conceptualization. If required, revise the thesis in accordance with examiners' comments submit a written record of thesis revisions to your h ead of college or discipline and the grs, preferably in table format and in neutral tone.